Not School

I have never let my schooling interfere with my education. -- Mark Twain

Sunday, February 12, 2006

Relevant information


    I once had a history class in which we studied world geography-- sort of. We had to be able to write in the names of all 190-odd countries on a map, and we had to know the names of all their capitals. We worked up to this point over the course of a semester.

    Today I've been reading about Iran, which got me thinking about how we didn't learn, in that long-ago class, about the Strait of Hormuz. My teacher made no decision about which places were important to know about; every country and capital was treated as equally important, and no natural features (deserts, mountains, straits) were covered at all. It's a perfect example of teaching the shallow overview which turns out to be largely useless, instead of picking and choosing the critical elements and studying them in depth.

    I submit that it is far more important for Americans to know about the Strait of Hormuz than to know where Myanmar is. Consider (here's the reference I used):

    • The Strait of Hormuz leads from the Persian Gulf out into the ocean.
    • 90% of Persian Gulf oil passes through the Strait of Hormuz on tankers.
    • 22% of US oil imports, 30% of Western European oil imports, and 76% of Japanese oil imports come from the Persian Gulf.
    • This oil must go through one of two shipping lanes, each only 1 mile wide.
    • The Strait of Hormuz is right off the coast of Iran.
    • Iran has said on several occasions that it will shut down the Strait if threatened.

    The majority of Americans support military action against Iran. I have to wonder if they would still support this if they understood that the world's largest economies will lose anywhere from a quarter to three quarters of their oil, engendering a global economic depression? Sure, Americans support bombing Iran... we may know that the capital of Ecuador is Quito, but most of us have never heard the term "oil chokepoint".

    2 Comments:

    Anonymous Anonymous said...

    Hello,

    I found your blog while searching for information about homeschooling. I love your writing style, and agree with so many things you write, it is really fun to read this.
    Best wishes for you and your wonderful children.
    Astrid Brown

    February 13, 2006 5:43 PM  
    Blogger Production Is Wealth said...

    Thanks! Always glad to have another reader....

    February 13, 2006 8:50 PM  

    Post a Comment

    << Home